What if the true value of education isn’t just what students know, but who they become? In a world where technical skills often overshadow other qualities, Professor Phil Cummins, founder of the School for Tomorrow, offers a refreshing perspective that prioritises character at the centre of learning. His holistic approach challenges us to see character development not merely as a part, but as a well-orchestrated symphony made up of five key elements: the who (our identity), the what (our values), the why (our purpose), the how (our actions), and the where (our context). Educators play a crucial role in guiding students through this symphony, helping them understand and develop the five pillars of character in their personal and leadership journeys.
The Who: Identity as Your GPS
Think of your identity as the GPS of your life. Just as a GPS needs to know your current location before it can guide you anywhere, understanding who you are provides the essential starting point for all meaningful growth and decision-making. This self-awareness doesn’t limit you; it empowers you to make authentic choices about your path, much like a master chef who understands their culinary identity.
Consider a master chef who has spent years developing their culinary identity. They know their strengths (perhaps through an intuitive understanding of flavours), their limitations (maybe they struggle with pastry work), and their unique style (a fusion of traditional techniques with modern presentation). This self-awareness doesn’t limit them; it empowers them to make authentic choices about which restaurants to work in, what dishes to create, and how to continue growing. Similarly, self-reflection is a key tool in understanding our own identities, helping us identify our strengths, limitations, and unique styles, and empowering us to make authentic choices in our personal and leadership growth.
Your identity is like a fingerprint, wholly unique yet constantly evolving. It’s shaped by your experiences, relationships, failures, and triumphs, creating a distinctive pattern that influences every choice you make. When young people understand their identity deeply, they’re less likely to be swayed by peer pressure or societal expectations that don’t align with their authentic selves.
The What: Values as Your North Star
If identity is your GPS, then values serve as your North Star, the fixed point that keeps you oriented even when the terrain gets rough. Values are like the roots of a mighty oak tree: invisible to most observers but essential for stability and growth. They provide a sense of security and an anchor in the face of ethical dilemmas, guiding your decisions and actions.
Imagine two learners facing the same ethical dilemma: finding a wallet full of cash on school grounds. One learner, whose family has always emphasised honesty and integrity, immediately considers returning it to the lost property. Another learner, perhaps raised in an environment where survival often trumped idealism, might think about keeping the money. Neither response is determined solely by the situation; both are filtered through the lens of deeply held values.
Values serve as a personal constitution, your fundamental principles that guide behaviour when external laws are absent or unclear. They distinguish between doing what is legal and what is morally right, between following the crowd and following your conscience. A young person with clearly defined values is like a ship with a dependable compass, capable of navigating the storms of adolescence and emerging adulthood with confidence and direction.
The Why: Purpose as Your Life’s Screenplay
Purpose is the screenplay of your life story. While identity reveals who the main character is, and values provide the moral framework, purpose gives your story direction, meaning, and a compelling plot. It’s what transforms a random series of events into a meaningful narrative. Purpose is like a powerful engine that can carry you through the inevitable mountains and valleys of life, inspiring you to achieve your goals and make a difference.
Consider the difference between two gardeners. One plants flowers because they’re pretty, following trends and seasonal fashions. The other plants have been planted with a purpose—perhaps to create a healing garden for hospital patients, or to provide habitat for endangered butterflies. Both may use similar techniques and achieve beautiful results, but the second gardener’s work carries deeper significance and sustained motivation.
Purpose is like a powerful engine that can carry you through the inevitable mountains and valleys of life. When a student discovers they want to become a doctor not just for the prestige or salary, but because they genuinely want to heal people and reduce suffering in the world, that purpose becomes fuel for the long journey through medical school, residency, and beyond.
Without purpose, even the most talented individuals can find themselves drifting, like a ship without wind in its sails. With it, ordinary people can achieve extraordinary things, driven by a sense that their actions matter in the broader fabric of human experience.
The How: Actions as Your Daily Votes
If purpose is your life’s screenplay, then your actions are the daily votes you cast for the kind of person you want to become. Every choice, no matter how small, is like dropping a pebble into a pond, creating ripples that extend far beyond the initial splash.
Think of actions as deposits in your character’s bank account. A learner who consistently chooses to help struggling classmates makes deposits of kindness and generosity. Another who regularly meets deadlines builds a portfolio of reliability and discipline. Over time, these accumulated actions compound like interest, forming a reputation and, more importantly, strengthening neural pathways that make similar choices easier in the future.
Actions are where the rubber meets the road in character development. You can have noble values and inspiring purposes. However, without consistent actions that align with them, they remain merely good intentions. It’s like having a beautiful architectural blueprint but never laying the foundation or raising the walls.
The magic happens in the ordinary moments, choosing to listen when someone needs to talk, picking up litter even when no one is watching, or pushing on when motivation wanes. These seemingly minor choices are, in fact, the building blocks of exceptional character, much like individual threads that, when woven together, form a fabric of integrity.
The Where: Context as Your Stage
Context is the stage upon which your character performs. Just as a theatrical performance is influenced by the theatre, lighting, and audience, your character development is profoundly shaped by your environment: your family, school, community, culture, and the historical moment in which you live.
Consider how the same seed might grow differently depending on whether it’s planted in rich soil with ample sunlight or in rocky ground with limited water. The genetic potential of the seed remains constant, but the environment significantly influences how that potential is expressed. Similarly, your character develops based on the circumstances you encounter.
A student raised in a community that values education will likely develop different relationship patterns with learning than one from an environment where academic achievement is seen as a form of “selling out.” Neither context is inherently good or bad, but understanding your context helps you make conscious choices about which environmental influences to embrace and which to transcend.
Context awareness also fosters empathy. When you recognise that everyone performs on their unique stage, with their own set of props, lighting, and audience expectations, it becomes easier to show grace to those whose choices might seem incomprehensible from your perspective. It’s the difference between judging someone for being unprepared and recognising they might not have had access to the same resources or support systems that you take for granted, which are so common in our society.
The Dance of the Five Elements
Cummins’ framework recognises that these five elements don’t operate in isolation; they dance together in a complex, ever-evolving choreography. Your identity influences your values, which in turn shape your purpose, guiding your actions within the context of your environment. But the dance moves in all directions: your actions also reshape your identity, your context can challenge your values, and your purpose might evolve as you grow. The five pillars are thus interconnected, each relying on the others for support and strength.
This dynamic interaction is what makes character development so engaging and demanding. It’s not a straightforward process where you master one aspect before moving on to another. Instead, it’s more like learning to juggle; you are always managing all five elements at once, gradually honing the ability to keep them all in smooth motion.
In conclusion, Professor Cummins’ five-dimensional framework aligns well with the Rudder4Success Leadership and Personal Development Framework (RLPDF), which emphasises that “changing who we are (our identity) begins with mastering our feelings and building genuine connections with others, meaning changing what we do.”
Both frameworks acknowledge that character and leadership development are not about quick fixes or superficial skill acquisition. Instead, they recognise the deep interconnection of identity, values, purpose, actions, and context that Cummins highlights. Simultaneously, Rudder4Success offers vital insights into the role of emotional intelligence, which includes “self-awareness, social awareness, self-management, relationship management and responsible decision-making.” Professor Cummins provides a blueprint for understanding oneself across five key dimensions, while Rudder4Success converts this self-awareness into practical tools to build emotional and social intelligence.
Together, they offer a comprehensive blueprint for developing not only successful individuals but also character-driven leaders who are self-aware and capable of forming genuine connections with others in pursuit of a higher purpose. In a world that often prioritises achievement over character, these frameworks remind us that true, lasting success arises from within through deep self-understanding and engaging with others through wisdom, empathy, and genuine care.
As we prepare young people for an uncertain future, perhaps the greatest gift we can give them is not just knowledge or skills, but an integrated understanding of character, relationships, and purpose that both frameworks so powerfully advocate.
#CharacterDevelopment #LeadershipDevelopment #PersonalGrowth #EmotionalIntelligence #SocialEmotionalLearning #SEL #Education #YouthDevelopment #IdentityFormation #Values #Purpose #Mindfulness #SelfAwareness #Authenticity #IntegrityMatters